Skip to main content

Scottsboro Boys' Case - Facts

This is the eleventh post of the series 'LegalTrek'. The last post was 'The Man On The Cigarette Packet'. This post explains is about the facts of the Scottsboro Boys' Case - the case that inspired Harper Lee to write 'To Kill A Mocking Bird'.
Samuel Leibowitz with the Scottsboro Boys - Courtesy Wikipedia

How I Became A Lawyer।। Allahabad High Court Is Born।।Lucknow Bench - Historical Necessity।। Introduction to Setalvad।। Benches and The Law Commission।। Court of Appeal – Not A Good Idea: Some Suggestions।। Courtroom - Finest Legal Biography।। Leibowitz - The First Case।। Art of Cross Examination।। The Man on the Cigarette Packet।। Scottsboro Boys' Case - Facts।।

In later life, Leibowitz would often go on vacation but wherever he went, he would visit the court. He preferred courtrooms to the monuments. Once he visited Miami courthouse. In the case there, there wasn't anything to interest him except for the jury box: there was a black man in the jury. During lunch time, Leibowitz asked the lawyer about it. The lawyer answered (from the book 'Courtroom'),
'Yes, it is something new. This is the first time in our state we have had a nigger on a jury and it's all on account of a son-of-a-bitch named Samuel Leibowitz from New York. He came down to Alabama a few years ago to try a case and somehow he got to the Supreme Court in Washington, and damned if we haven't had to put niggers on our juries over since.' 
This was due to Scottsboro Boys' case.

Scottsboro Boys' case is not only the most talked about US constitutional case of the 20th century but is also a milestone in the area of civil rights. It had gone to US Supreme Court twice and both times, the death penalty was set aside and the case was sent back for re-hearing; it is the only case, where the US Supreme Court looked into facts of the case. 

The case was tried in Albama. Harper Lee used to live there. The case had impact on her. At that time,  she was six year old, the same age as of Scout, who is the protagonist of the book 'To Kill A Mocking Bird'. 

1930's was a time of depression in the US. Hobos often went places from one place to other on freight trains in search of jobs. On March 25, 1931, nine Blacks (aged from 12 to nineteen) were pulled off from a freight train in Alabama and were initially arrested for assaulting white boys on the train. There were two young white women Ms. Victoria Price and Ms. Ruby Bates on the train too. The Blacks were later allegedly charged for raping them in a gondola of the same train.  

On the request of the State, they were tried in three groups in Scottsboro (this is why it is known as Scottsboro Boys' case).  Between April 7-9,1931, eight of the Scottsboro Boys were sentenced to death.  The trial of the ninth one Roy Wright (the youngest 12 or 13 years old) ended in a mistrial when some jurors held out for a death sentence even though the prosecution asked for life imprisonment. 

Their executions were stayed pending appeals before Alabama Supreme Court. In between the hearing before the Supreme Court a new development took place. On January 5, 1932, in a letter Ruby Bates denied that she was raped. However in March, 1932, the Alabama Supreme Court by a vote of 6-1, affirmed the convictions of seven of the boys over the strong dissent by Chief Justice John Arderson that the accused were given a fair trial (242 Ala. 524). The conviction of one of them, Eugene Williams aged 13 years was reversed on the grounds that he was a juvenile under state law. The news of their convictions spread and the plight of the Scottsboro Boys became a 'cause celebre'. 

In the next post, we will talk about what happened in the US Supreme Court.

#LegalTrek #YatindraSingh 
#Courtroom #SamuelLeibowitz
#ToKillAMockingBird, #ScottsboroBoysCase


Popular posts from this blog


Two areas are close to my heart, namely uniform civil code and population control. I had drafted bills in late 1990's before I was  offered judgeship. The bills were distributed in the Parliament at that time but before they could be introduced (whether as a bill from the public or as a private member bill) the Parliament was dissolved. 
The Central government has asked the Law Commission to examine the issue of implementing the  Uniform Civil Code in detail and submit a report. I thought of publishing the bill relating to Uniform Civil Code that I had drafted.


Sometime ago, there were headlines in the newspaper 'Night Drama that did not succeed'. Here is the story of a night drama that succeeded. 
Kalyan Singh was the Chief Minister of Uttar Pradesh and Romesh Bhandari was the Governor. He,  illegally dismissed the Kalyan Singh Government on 21st February, 1998.  A writ petition was filed the smae night and he was reinstated. This is the only time that the a deposed head of a State was pput back in saddle by the court. Here is the account of the same. 
The writ petition at the Allahabad High Court was filed by Dr. NKS Gaur, an MLA from Allahabad North and Minister of Higher Education in UP, but for the sake of convenience, the case is referred as 'the Kalyan-Singh case'.  
During my tenure as a judge, it has been matter of speculation/ complaint how I became Additional Advocate General and why was this case entrusted to me. This is explained in Appendix-I to this article. In order to complete the picture, Romesh Bhandari's …


Article 21 of the Constitution guarantees right to the life and liberty. Right to move to the court to enforce Article 21 was suspended under Article 359 of the Constitution during internal emergency (1975-77). Soon a question arose if, in such a situation, a writ of Habeas Corpus is maintainable? ADM Jabalpur Vs Shiv Kant Shukla AIR 1976 SC 1207 : (1976)2 scc 521: 1976 UJ (SC) 610: 1976 Cr LR (SC) 303: 1976 CrL J 1945 (SC) (the Habeas Corpus case) dealt with this question. This article, written 20 years after the aforesaid case was decided, narrates about the incidents, lawyers and judges connected with that case and what has happened to them.
‘The time has come’ The Walrus said ‘To talk of many things:
Of shoes and ships and sealing wax-
Of cabbages - and kings-
And why the sea is boiling hot-
And whether pigs have wings’ Through the Looking Glass; Lewis Carroll